We had a lovely dinner on the patio area at the front! It was beautiful and cozy! Our cocktails were delicious and our pizza was amazing! We ordered 3 pizzas sound crazy but we came all the way from Southern, IN so we were ALL IN with our Wheated experience. All of our pizzas were delicious but our fav was the simple New York style “cheese” pizza! Never have I ever loved that type of pizza so much! We highly recommend this sweet spot to everyone we know looking for delicious pizza and fun drink choices!
Overview
Discover Wheated, a standout pizza restaurant located at 1553 Bardstown Rd, Louisville, KY 40205, United States. Set inside a charming house in the Highlands, this Brooklyn-born concept brings sourdough pizza, thoughtfully sourced toppings, creative cocktails, and an intimate neighbourhood atmosphere to Louisville. From a food blogger’s perspective, Wheated is especially compelling because its pizza begins with the crust: tangy, blistered, crisp underneath, and pleasantly chewy through the centre. That attention to fermentation gives each pie considerably more character than a typical neighbourhood pizza.
The menu is deliberately focused, covering New York-style and specialty pizzas alongside meatballs, Caesar salad, seasonal small plates, cocktails, beer, and desserts. Wheated in Louisville is generally a mid-range dinner destination, with diners often spending more than they would at a standard takeaway pizzeria because of the artisan ingredients and craft approach. Outdoor patio seating, dine-in service, takeaway, vegan options, high chairs, and wheelchair accessibility add flexibility for different groups. The restaurant currently opens for dinner Wednesday through Sunday and is closed Monday and Tuesday.
A first-time visitor should seriously consider the Bensonhurst Pizza, one of the restaurant’s recurring customer favourites. Its thin sourdough base develops a pronounced char and crisp edge while retaining enough chew to support the toppings without becoming heavy. Reviewers repeatedly praise the crust for its crunch, flavour, and balance, which is the clearest reason Wheated competes with the best restaurants in Louisville for serious pizza lovers.
The Kentucky Brighton Beach is another memorable choice. It brings a more distinctive regional personality to the menu while retaining the restaurant’s New York pizza foundations. One 2026 customer called the pie delicious alongside the restaurant’s meatballs and smoked-maple Old Fashioned. For a simpler test of technique, the New York-style Cheese Pizza is arguably even more revealing: sauce, cheese, fermentation, and oven char have nowhere to hide. Diners consistently praise its balance and crispness.
Customer feedback is notably enthusiastic. A June 2026 diner praised the crust for having the ideal combination of “char, crispness, and chew,” while another described it as the best pizza they had eaten after trying notable pizzas in Italy, New York, and Arizona. Recent community reviews also highlight excellent ingredients and phenomenal sourdough crust, though several diners note that prices are relatively high and the restaurant becomes extremely busy.
The dining room is small, cosy, and stylish without feeling formal. Window seating and the front patio provide pleasant views of Bardstown Road, while cocktails make the restaurant equally appealing for date nights and relaxed evenings with friends. The trade-off is noise: peak dinner periods can become lively enough to make conversation harder.
For diners seeking distinctive local dining experiences, Wheated deserves attention for its sourdough crust, creative pizzas, excellent meatballs, and inviting Highlands setting. Call +1 502-963-5616 and visit for a carefully crafted pizza that proves great dough can transform a familiar comfort food into something memorable.
Good to know
Service options
✓ Outdoor seating ✓ Takeaway ✓ Dine-in ✓ DeliveryHighlights
✓ Fast service ✓ Great beer selection ✓ Great cocktailsPopular for
✓ Dinner ✓ Solo diningAccessibility
✓ Wheelchair-accessible car park ✓ Wheelchair-accessible entrance ✓ Wheelchair-accessible seatingOfferings
✓ Alcohol ✓ Beer ✓ Cocktails ✓ Comfort food ✓ Spirits ✓ Vegetarian options ✓ WineDining options
✓ Dinner ✓ Dessert ✓ Seating ✓ Table serviceAmenities
✓ Bar on site ✓ ToiletAtmosphere
✓ Casual ✓ Cosy ✓ TrendyCrowd
✓ Family friendly ✓ Groups ✓ LocalsPayments
✓ Credit cards ✓ Debit cardsChildren
✓ Good for kids ✓ High chairsParking
✓ Free of charge street parking ✓ Paid street parking ✓ ParkingPhotos
1 / 4
Location
Reviews
- No ratings yet 213 reviews
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ As a Louisville realtor who’s always exploring local spots to share with clients and friends, Wheated Louisville is one of my favorite neighborhood restaurants! The pizza is wood-fired and delicious—crispy, flavorful, and made with the freshest ingredients. The Caesar salad is honestly one of the best in Louisville, and you have to try the tiramisu—it’s next-level! The cocktails are creative, the service is always great, and the patio is the perfect spot to unwind after a busy day showing homes or closing deals. If you’re looking for good pizza in Louisville, or a cozy date night spot near The Highlands, Wheated should be at the top of your list. It’s one of those local gems that perfectly blends incredible food, great drinks, and Louisville charm. #LouisvilleEats #WheatedLouisville #PizzaInLouisville #LouisvilleRealtor #LouisvilleRestaurants #GermantownLouisville #HighlandsLouisville #DateNightLouisville
This place is truly special. The fresh ingredients and unique flavors are amazing. I can honestly say that its the best tasting pizza ive ever had. The cocktail are fun and delicious. The service is always great and if you can sit outside on a nice day its pretty awesome. We love it here!
Amazing pizza. I went with the artichoke, olive, and spinach pizza. I don't normally like artichokes so it was a risk but it paid off massively. The garlic and oil was a deep, satisfying flavor as the base and the artichoke and olives added a lighter flavor. My pizza was my favorite, but the table-favorite was the Bay Ridge that had a vodka sauce base. The drinks were unique and not-too-sweet. The pineapple cardamom drink was a successful flavor profile. Highly recommend. Service was excellent. We got a visit from an owner and Michael helped us box our pizzas. Great people helped make it a great experience! Thanks!
Really good pie. Cocktails were excellent as was the service. Got there at 5pm opening on a Saturday and our part of 4 was seated immediately. They had a nice cocktail special before 6pm -$4 off their $14 cocktails. We were finished by 6:15pm. Pizzas were authentic Brooklyn style - as much as any I have had and I've had many. Highly recommended.
Great new find!!! Service and atmosphere were outstanding. Pizza’s are fantastic, the crust was perfectly cooked. We had the Supreme, NY Slice with sausage and pepperoni and the Bayridge. So good!! Owner/chef even came out to check in! Highly recommend.
Carissa was our server. All of the staff were friendly and hospitable. Carissa gave us a recommendation about the ricotta and marinara dip (it was AMAZING). They have hot sauce and Mike’s hot honey- we took a bottle home! Onto the bread and butter- this dough and it’s texture is by far one of the best I’ve encountered. It’s flavorful, cooked to perfection and has the right amount of crispness. Don’t let my floppy pizza pic fool you, it is a very study pizza! Drizzle some Nikes hot honey, fold that bad boy in half and dunk it in the ricotta/marinara dip and prepared to be dazzled. Honorable mention- their women’s restroom has a dungeon lock and empty photo frames, that give a really artistic aesthetic. I will be back…. Many times I fear. Thanks for dinner Wheated Staff!
Best pizza in Lou! Couldn't be more pleased to have this gem in my neighborhood. Really loved the Prospect Park South pizza and also was blown away by the cocktails - particularly the Run Rabbit Run seasonal drank Very cute and cozy atmosphere for the holidays, as well!